Where do we go from here

By my calculations, it’s been nearly a full year since I last posted when Gamecock Man at Garnet and Black Attack was so gracious to exchange Q&A’s with me last year just a few days prior to the beginning of the end of the 2010 UGA football season. Since then, we’ve gone through the whole turmoil that was losing four in a row, a heartbreaking loss to Florida, losing to Auburn when Mike Bobo decided to take his foot off the gas, and then the humiliating end to 2010 with the worst lack of effort I’ve seen from a Mark Richt coached team against UCF. The whole time last year, there were many times when I wanted to weigh in and add my thoughts, but I remembered a post by Paul Westerdawg a few years ago:

You want to know why I haven’t blogged much the past few weeks? What’s to say? From mid 2005-2008, the song has remained mostly the same. We got a 6 game reprieve from our problems in late 2007, but it’s been the same problems for most of that period. It gets redundant saying the same things over and over. “If we tackle well, don’t get lots of penalties and score points in the redzone, blah, blah, blah.” It gets old talking about that every week.

This is the mindset I’ve pretty much been in since I got back from the game in Columbia last year and didn’t really feel like talking about UGA football much. Much to commenter Darth’s delight, I’ve decided to finally update something here.

Now we sit here roughly 36 days away from opening kick-off in the Georgia Dome against Boise State and I don’t really know how I should feel about the upcoming season. Normally, this is a time of great excitement and anticipation for me, but frankly I’m not truly feeling it this year. I suppose it’s the old “fool me once – shame on you, fool me twice – shame on me” syndrome”. While I’d love to buy into the offseason hype and believe everything is going to be okay and it’ll be just like 2002-2005 all over again, it’s just too soon for me right now to do that. I’m firmly in the wait-and-see camp.

With all that said, now I have to figure out where I go from here on out to make this blog interesting without getting myself too worked up. I suppose an easy topic this off-season has been the question of how warm the seat on which Mark Richt resides truly is. However, this is a touchy subject and I don’t want to get in a pissing war with these guys who are utterly done with Mark Richt nor do I want to get in a pissing war with these guys who believe that Mark Richt is going to turn this thing around by citing examples such as not giving up on Bear Bryant or Vince Dooley when they went through rough stretches in the middle of their careers and the schools were subsequently rewarded by sticking with their men.

Personally, I believe both are right and wrong to an extent. The “cold blooded sausage makers” are right in that the argument that we can’t get anybody better than Mark Richt is false considering there are a ton of coaches that we could have hired that would have done much better over the last three years than Mark Richt. I also believe that they’re wrong in completely writing off Mark Richt because I genuinely believe he truly realizes how far awry the program had slipped and he’s now reinventing himself and how the program goes about its business in a way that hasn’t been there since DJ Shockley was running the show in Athens.

I believe TKK is right in that given a long enough sample size we are going to see highs and lows and what we’re seeing in Athens the past few years is an inevitable low point that would occur for any coach given enough time in any high profile job (even the great Urban Meyer lost five games last year and Nick Saban lost six games his first year in Tuscaloosa). I also believe he’s wrong in citing the Bryant and Dooley examples, because it’s never as simple as saying that “my belief must be true because everything that has ever happened in the past will happen again”. While Mark Richt very well may turn it around, the idea that he should be held onto by citing the Bryant and Dooley examples is false. Mark Richt should be retained because performance on the field improves this year, not because history says he should.

I suppose the point I’m getting at is that the fanbase is divided right now (however, it’s not in the black and white manner that these guys would have you believe). While there are certainly a few that will defend Richt to the end and some that are truly done with him, I believe the bulk of us rest somewhere in the middle. We know that the program isn’t where it can and should be, but we also don’t believe that we should just keep railing on how much we want Richt gone. The fact of the matter is that Mark Richt is the coach right now and will be for 2011. There’s no need to get worked up about who we could get or when he’s going to get fired. In my mind, the goodwill he’s built up in Athens is all but gone, but the man is still the head coach at my alma mater and me bitching and moaning about him isn’t going to get him fired or retained any time soon. Ultimately what I’m saying is that it’s time to stop debating what will or won’t happen sometime in the next six-eight months and rather we should hope for the best from the young men and coaches that will represent our alma mater this fall. While I will truly never understand the perpetually optimistic UGA fan, I’ll also hold equal contempt for the fan that decides to spend all his/her time railing on how bad the current coaching staff/program is. At some point, you’ve got to get behind your program no matter how bad it gets and trust the people up top (i.e. Greg McGarity) will make the correct decision going forward.


7 responses to “Where do we go from here

  1. Welcome back, good to hear from you again. Thank you for summing up my feelings perfectly.

  2. Welcome Back. I basically disagree with everything you said regarding Mark Richt & the Football Program from 2005 until 2011. I still wonder if things would have been different if the 2005 recruits had not reporting to Athens with only 12 new players. If we get a new coach I wish him much success but I doubt that he will do better or even as well as Coach Richt.

  3. Booger Presley

    Bored with the same ole talk. The herd has been culled. The strong remain. Lets play some football. Let the chips fall where they may. The Dawgs suit up every fall regardless of who is at the helm. I love em just the same.

  4. Its a win win situation CMR turns the program around and we get wins or we hopefully get a better HC and could be setting good in a couple years depending on how much change a new coach bring in

  5. I agree with everything you said, but for the most part I disagree with 90% of it.

    Yes, the early years with Richt were wonderful, but were they? Consider the fact that the National Championship “Golden Era” of the SEC had not yet begun during Richt’s stretch from 2000-2005, coupled with the fact that UGA had only beaten Florida just once in Richt’s tenure during that time, and ask yourself: Was Richt really EVER that “great”?

    To the 10% I agree with above: yes, I will acknowledge that Richt is still the coach this season – nothing will change that now.

    But ask yourself this: If Richt wins 9 games in 2011, and the three losses are to Florida, Boise State, and South Carolina, even if Richt manages to coach his squad to an appearance in the SEC Championship but still loses to the West champion, does Richt still deserve the head-coaching job at Georgia in 2012?

    Now, keeping in mind the above question, acknowledge that a 9-3 season with an appearance in the SEC Title game would be a VAST improvement over the past 3 years. But despite that vast improvement, I can’t imagine many believing that the scenario I painted above would be enough of an improvement for Georgia fans. I would even go as far to say that many a Georgia fan – whether momentarily on the fence with Richt or not on the fence – would be willing to continue to allow Richt to stay in the driver’s seat of that program.

    My example is merely for the purpose of speculating ahead, because as much as you’d like to – you cannot ignore the elephant in the room, that elephant being Richt’s job status uncertainty.

    I apologize if I’ve lost anyone in this post, but if you take away anything from my rambling, please acknowledge this: Richt HAS to do something special this year, there are no “if’s”, “and’s”, or “but’s” about it. Last season was abysmal – a 6-7 year worth forgetting forever. And if Richt does somehow manage the rigorous challenge of turning around a 6-7 program to a 9-3 SEC team that makes an appearance in the SEC Title game, I still don’t think it’ll be enough.

    So, Georgia fans, if you had to bet money – how much would you put down on Richt being UGA’s head coach in 2012? Odds are 30% at best.

  6. correction to the above:

    would NOT be willing to continue to allow Richt to stay in the driver’s seat of that program.

  7. Boise State/UGA predictions?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s